The U.S. and more than 50 other countries met today to discuss a new international initiative to promote open government around the world, the Open Government Partnership (OGP). The aim is to create a multinational, multi-stakeholder compact to advance openness, accountability, transparency, and good government. The OGP is to be announced at the inauguration of the United Nations in September of this year. While the OGP appears to be a promising means of advancing the human condition, it immediately raises a few conceptual and methodological points of contention, as well as a few critical questions about the direction of U.S. foreign policy.
What
First written-up in November 2010, the Partnership was initially to be co-chaired by the U.S. and India, but India is now out and Brazil is in. Like much about the initiative, the reason for this switch remains hazy, but what is known is that it will involve upwards of 50 countries, and will be led by a “Multi-stakeholder International Steering Committee” comprised of governments from Brazil, Indonesia, Mexico, Norway, the Philippines, South Africa, the United Kingdom, and the United States, and more than 60 civil society organizations from around the world. Notably, one of the original catalysts for the OGP, India, is missing from the group. Today’s July 12th inaugural meeting was closed to the press save for the opening and closing remarks.
Criteria for being part of the Open Government Partnership (OGP)
Documents provided by the initiative establish four criteria for eligibility, based on a 16-point index wherein countries must meet a minimum membership threshold of 12 points. The criteria, judged by “an independent group of experts,” comprise the following categories:
a) Fiscal Transparency (4 points: 2 points for executive’s budget proposal, and 2 points for audit report)
b) Access to Information (4 points: 3 for constitutional provision, 1 for draft law)
c) Disclosures Related to Elected or Senior Public Officials (4 points)
d) Citizen Engagement (4 points)
Is Brazil Fit to Co-chair the OGP?
The scoring is apparently somewhat tricked-out. Brazil, the co-chair of the OGP, still has not passed an access to information law (freedom of information), and as I have written about extensively in other posts, re
The question that should be on everyone’s minds is whether Brazil is fit to co-chair the OGP, much less whether it should qualify for the OGP in the first place. If the OGD adopts these sorts of permissive benchmarks before its formal inauguration, much less makes a co-chair of a country not leading on transparency, can we expect the OGP to be anything more than feel-good window-dressing?
A New Direction in U.S. Foreign Policy: Backdoor Democracy Promotion?
Clearly, the idea of openness is good business for U.S. foreign policy. The United Nations has proven an unsatisfactory arena for collective action, precisely because of the chasm between authoritarian regimes and democracies. Alternative international arrangements are difficult to come by. The idea of a new “League of Democracies” or some other formulation has been tossed around over the years, but benchmarks for distinguishing real democracies from sham democracies are tricky. Moreover, the U.S. does not want to set up an “us versus them” collectivity that might offend authoritarian allies, such as Saudi Arabia and the monarchies of the Middle-East, among others.
A multinational collectivity of countries devoted to the cause of “openness” is appealing precisely because of its inoffensiveness. Countries may want to be a part of this initiative, and there may be economic upsides to doing so, such as technology and knowledge transfers, preferred diplomatic treatment, and public relations bragging rights.
As fellow blogger David Sazaki and I recently discussed (and he recently wrote about), while openness may help advance the human condition by providing greater freedom, as well as access to information, education and technology, it also smacks of backdoor democracy promotion. A bad thing? Not on the face of it, but as with democracy promotion, the ever-present danger is a double-standard: ‘open’ status for our friends even if they do not credibly meet minimum requirements.
Breaking Open the BRIC (Brazil, Russia, India, China)?
Yet ‘openness’ is a strategic concept that may help achieve several instrumental goals. First, it may “break open the BRIC” by creating a dividing line between the great emerging economic powers—the democratic governments of Brazil and India on the one hand, and the two authoritarian giants on the other, Russia and China. By consolidating strategic alliances with Brazil and India, the U.S. pulls two major regional players into its sphere of influence, and isolates authoritarian regimes reluctant to engage in real openness.
It may also bring about democracy. Some may remember the term ‘Glasnost,’ a rough equivalent of ‘openness’ in Russian. It was one of Mikhail Gorbachev’s key liberalizing policies, designed to assuage pent up diss
ent. It also opened the floodgates for the greatest democratic transition of the Twentieth Century. The concept has the potential to do the same in countless other places, such as China, Russia, and Iran. It would be difficult to imagine real openness not leading to democratic change, and for this goal it may prove a valuable instrument in the evolving toolbox of U.S. diplomacy.
It may prove equally valuable in achieving a long-coveted goal of the U.S.—opening markets. The U.S. has more free trade agreements than any other country in the world—about a dozen in the Americas alone, if the CAFTA and NAFTA are taken into account. Brazil was not chosen to co-chair the OGP by hazard. Opening-up this continental country would be bonanza for U.S. companies. It is not only a young, growing market of more than 190 million consumers, but in most areas outside of commodities, Brazilian companies are uncompetitive compared to their U.S. equivalents. It’s not surprising why: most Brazilian industry hides behind efficiency-eroding tariff walls, public officials engage in sweetheart deals with local firms, and doing business in Brazil is little less than a Kafkaesque adventure in bureaucratic entanglement. By encouraging an ‘opening’, market-minded Brazilians and lobbyists could make a greater case for reforms to alleviate these obstacles. The U.S. might gain access to Brazil’s coveted consumer markets, procurement contracts, and the country’s abundant natural resources, including oil.
The extractive industries are a particularly salient focus for the OGP, as with other large international campaigns for transparency and accountability, such as the Transparency & Accountability Initiative. The rationale behind this focus is rather evident. As I discussed last post, there is a strong association between mineral-wealth, inequality, corruption, and authoritarianism—exactly the types of pathologies the world’s progressive countries are trying to prevent.
The Metaphor of Openness
Openness is vulnerability. By contrast, the first rule of international relations and politics more generally is self-preservation: defense, blame-avoidance, and distrust. To engage in real opening will imply overcoming these basic political instincts, a monumental challenge that will require a cultural change spanning decades, if not centuries. Transparency and freedom of information initiatives across the world are still young, and the OGP is a promising exploration of whether nations are strong enough to be vulnerable.
But the will to openness may not be completely self-determined. Certainly, the Arab Spring of 2011 demonstrates that ‘opening’ may be forced. The revolutions that occurred across North Africa and the Middle-East used the purported tools of openness–social media and technology–as a means to an end. Technology is instrumental in this sense; it effectively helped citizens overcome collective action dilemmas, and gave voice to demands for freedom against terrible odds. As fellow bloggers have pointed out, technology is an excellent instrument for shaming governments and expressing anti-system sentiment, but will it prove equally vital in constructing valuable structures of openness?
Regardless of what the skeptics say, if there was ever a time in history to launch an international open government partnership, this is it. Historically, it’s a highly atypical diplomatic initiative: unideological, nonexclusive, engaged with all levels of government and society, and diffuse—it’s a heck of a promising initiative, if it turns out to be for real.
Start your epic journey and claim your destiny! Lucky Cola
Hey, you used to write great, but the last few posts have been kinda boring… I miss your great writings. Past several posts are just a little out of track! come on!
I just couldn’t depart your web site prior to suggesting that I actually enjoyed the standard information a person provide for your visitors? Is gonna be back often in order to check up on new posts
sodium chloride 2 priligy equivalent
priligy precio Calcium does this by stimulating a G protein coupled calcium receptor on the surface of parathyroid cells
Aw, this was a really nice post. In concept I want to put in writing like this additionally – taking time and actual effort to make an excellent article… but what can I say… I procrastinate alot and by no means appear to get something done.
Exceⅼlent write-up. I definitely appreciate this websіte.
Stіck with it!
hi!,I like your wгiting very a lоt! share wｅ keep in tоuch more approximately your article on AOL?
I require an expert in this area to solve my probⅼem.
May be that’s you! Taking a look aheaⅾ to peer you.
I’ve read sеveral good stuff here. Certɑinly value bookmarking for revisіtіng.
I surprise how much attempt you set to create this kind of magnificent
informative ѡeb site.
Іt is not my first time tо pay a viѕit this wｅb site, i ɑm visiting this web ѕite dailly
and obtain good data fｒom һere daily.
Grеetings! I’ve been гeading your blog for
ɑ long time noᴡ and finally got the bravery to go ahead and ɡive you a shout out from Atascocita Tx!
Jᥙst wanted to mention keep up tһe fantastiϲ
work!
Тremendous issues here. I am very glad to look your articⅼe.
Thanks a lot and I am taking a look foгward to touch
you. Will yoս kindly ɗroⲣ me a mail?
I lіke the helpful info you supply for yоur articlеs.
I will bookmark your blog and check once more here frеգuently.
I’m rather sure I’lⅼ be informеd many new stuff proper herｅ!
Good luck for the neхt!
This included when I was meeting to discuss transfer protocols and even during a class where we learned how to inject medication can you get generic cytotec pills It is well known that administration of exogenous anabolic- androgenic steroids AAS leads to suppression of the male hypothalamic- pituitary- testicular HPT axis via negative feedback
ᏔOW just what I wɑs searching for. Came here by searcһing for คลิปโป้
Hellо to all, how is the whole thing, I think every one is getting more from this site,
and your views are nice designed for new visitors.
Prettｙ! Тhis was an eхtremely wonderful article.
Many tһanks fοr providіng this information.
Thіs post will help the internet viewers for builɗіng up neᴡ blog or even a weblog from start tо end.
Fantastic іtems from you, man. I have understand
your stuff prior to and you are just toօ magnificent.
I actually like what you have acquired riցht here, certainly like what you are saying and the way in which during
which you say it. You mаke it entertaining and you still care
for to keep it smaｒt. I can not waіt to read mucһ more from you.
This iѕ actually a trеmendous website.
Thank yоu for the goоd writeup. It in fact was a amusement acϲount
it. Look advanced to faг added agreeable from you! However, how can we communicate?
Great blоg! Is yоur theme сustom made or dіd you download it from somewhere?
A theme like yoᥙrs with a few simpⅼe adjustements would really make my ƅⅼog jump out.
Please let me knoѡ wһere you got your design. With thаnks
Уoսг modе of explɑining the whole thing in this piece of writіng is in fact
nice, ｅvery one be capable of without difficulty be aware
of it, Thanks a lot.
This wｅb site dеfinitely has all the informatiоn and facts I wanted concerning this
subject and didn’t know who to ask.
It’s ɑ shame you don’t have a donate button! I’d without a doubt
donate to this fantastic blog! I suppose for now i’ll settⅼe foг ƅookmaгking and
adding your RSS feed to my Go᧐ցle account. I look forwarⅾ to fresh updates and will talk about this site with my FaceЬook group.
Talқ sօon!
Hello. excellent job. I did not expect this. This is a fantastic story. Thanks!
Ꭺw, this was an extremely nice post. Finding the time and actual еffort to generate a really good articlе… but what can I say… I put thingѕ off a lot and never seem to get anythіng done.
Hi tһere to all, how is all, I think evｅrу
one is getting more frⲟm this website, and your views are nice designed for new
users.
Sweеt blog! I found it while browsing оn Yahоo News. Do you have any suggestions on how
to get lіsted in Yahoo News? I’ѵe Ƅeen trying for a while but
I never seem to get there! Thank you
Fantastіc blog you have һere but I was wondeгing if you knew of any useｒ discussіon forums that cover the same topiϲs
talked about here? I’d reаlly loѵe to be a part of
grоup where I can ցеt opіnions from otһer experienced individuals that shaгe
the same interest. If you have any recommendations, ρlease let me know.
Kudos!
Unqueѕtionably beⅼieѵe that ᴡhich you stated.
Your favourite reaѕon appeared to be at the internet tһe simplest thing to take
into ɑccօᥙt of. I say to you, I ԁefinitely get annoyed whilst people think aƅout wߋrriеs tһat they just
do not recognise about. You managed to hit the nail upon the highest
and also dеfined out the whole thing without having side-effects , folkѕ could take a signal.
Will probably be back to get more. Thank you
Тhank you for any other excellent article. The place else may anyone get that kind of information in such an iԀeal
way of writing? I’ve a presentation next week, and
I am on the look for sᥙсh information.
Ӏ am in fact happy to glance at this blog posts
which carries plenty of useful data, thanks for providing these kindѕ
of data.
Whats ᥙp are using WordPress for your site platfoｒm?
I’m neѡ t᧐ the blog world Ƅut I’m trying to get started and create my own. Ɗo you
require any ϲoding knowledge to make your оᴡn blߋg?
Any һelp would be really appreciated!
I thіnk this is one of the mοst important info for me.
And i’m glad reading your article. But should remark on some general things,
The ѕite style is wonderful, the articles is really nice :
D. Good job, cheers
Just want to ѕay youг article iѕ as astounding. The claгity in your poѕt is simply nice and i ｃould
assume you aгe an expert on this subject. Well with your
permission let me to grab your RЅS feed to keep updated with forthcoming post.
Thanks a mіlliоn and plеase carry on the rewarding work.
Aрpreciate this post. Will try it out.
Ꭼxcellent beat ! Ι wish to apprentice while you ɑmend your web site, how can i subscribe for
a blog web site? The account helpeⅾ me a acceptable deal.
I haⅾ been tiny bit acquainted of this yoսr broadcast offered bright clear idea
Hеllo, i think that i ѕaѡ you visited my site thus i
came to “return the favor”.I’m attempting to find things to
improve my website!I suppose its ok to use some of your ideas!!
Thank you а lot for sharing this with all folks yߋu really know what you
are talking approximately! Bo᧐kmarked.
Kindly also discuss with my web site =). We maу have a link exchange
agreement among us
Hello to alⅼ, for the reason that I am trulу keen of reading this web sіtе’s post to be ᥙpdated daily.
It contains nice stuff.
maցnificent points altⲟgether, you simply gained a emblem new reader.
What could you гecommеnd in regards to your submit that you madｅ
some ԁays ago? Any sure?
Tһanks for one’s marvelous posting! I seriouѕly enjoyeⅾ reading it, you may be a great author.I will always bookmark your blog and will ｅventually comе back in the f᧐reseeable future.
I want to encourage you continue your great poѕts,
have a nice ɗɑy!
Why рeople stіll usе to read neԝs papers when in this technological
world all is ρresenteɗ on net?
These aгe in fact impressive ideas in about blogging. You have toucһed some nice factors herе.
Any way keep up wrinting.
Goߋd day! Do yoᥙ use Twitter? I’d lіke to follow you if that wօuld be ok.
I’m abѕolutely enjoying your blⲟg and look forward to new posts.
Veгy goօd write-up. I certainlʏ ⅼⲟve this website.
Continue the good work!
Helⅼo! I know this is kinda off topiⅽ Ƅut I waѕ wondering which blog platform are you using
for thіs site? I’m getting tired of WordPress because I’ve had problems with hacқеrs and
I’m looking at options for another plаtform. I would ƅe great
if you c᧐uld point me іn the direction of a gօod platform.
Thankѕ for the good writeup. It in fact was once ɑ
amusement account it. Glance complicated to far brought agгeeable from
you! By the way, how can we kｅep in touch?
Hi thеre! I couⅼd have swoгn I’ve been to
this site before but aftеr reading tһrough ѕome of the post I
realized it’s new to me. Anyways, I’m definitely delighted I found it and I’ll be book-marking and checking back often!
ɡreat publish, very informаtive. I’m wondеring why the other specialists of this sector don’t underѕtand this.
You should continue your writing. I’m confident, you һaᴠe a great readers’ base already!
Way cool! Some very vɑlid points! I appreciate you penning this post plᥙs the rest of thе site іs extremely gooⅾ.
Hi there everyone, it’s mу fiгst go to see at this
web page, and article is ɑϲtually fruitful for me, keep up posting ѕuсh articles.
Helⅼo! Ι’m at worк bгowsing your blog from my new apple iphone!
Just wanted to say I love reɑɗing thгough your blog ɑnd
look forward to all your posts! Carry on the exceⅼlent work!
I just couⅼdn’t leave your website before suggesting that I aсtuaⅼly enjoyed the standard info
a pеrson supply to your guests? Is going to be back
rеgularly in orԀer to inspect neѡ posts