A Freedom of Information Law in Brazil: Two Steps Forward, One Step Back

Posted on by gregmichener
Spread

Article written for freedominfo.org, a site curated by the D.C. based National Security Archive,  18 April, 2011: http://www.freedominfo.org/2011/04/rousseff-praise-brightens-outlook-for-brazilian-foi-bill/

Heartening events and significant setbacks added more drama to Brazil’s bid for a freedom of information (FOI) law this past week, but the overall outlook is considerably more promising now than before.

Heartening Events: President Rousseff Declares Support for FOI bill

President Dilma Rousseff confirmed her support for the FOI bill, (41/2010), which was approved by the Chamber of Deputies in April 2010 and has since been awaiting passage in the Senate. This is the first time that President Rousseff has publicly expressed support for the law since taking over from President Luiz Inácio Lula Da Silva in January, 2011. Bandwagoning on the President’s commitment, the media has begun to cover the issue with greater enthusiasm— a positive development for fostering much needed public awareness.

Brazil and the Open Government Partnership

The timing of the announcement coincides with U.S. President Barack Obama’s recent visit and an invitation to join an ‘Open Government Partnership,’ an effort that will include more than 70 countries. The Open Government Partnership was established last year with India’s Prime Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh and is expected to be announced at the opening of the United Nations in September of this year.

President Rousseff has set May 3rd, World Press Freedom Day, as the target date for enactment. At just over two weeks from now, this appears to be an excessively ambitious time horizon—barring some creative legislative maneuvering.

Significant Setback: the Unconstitutionality of Brazil’s FOI Bill

A second event of interest was the recognition of the FOI bill’s unconstitutionality last week in the Senate. Article 35 of the bill mandates the establishment of a ‘Mixed Evaluative Commission,’ to be composed of representatives of the Legislative, Executive and Judicial branches of government, to be responsible for deliberating on issues of classification. The problem is the Commission’s multi-branch composition, which apparently contradicts Article 2 of the 1988 Constitution: the three branches of government must be ‘independent’ of each other.

Why this issue was not discovered earlier, and debates of constitutional interpretation aside, nothing short of legislative wizardry will be required to pass the bill within the next two weeks let alone the next two months. The crux of the issue is that the lawmakers may have to amend the bill, sending it back to the Chamber of Deputies for re-approval and then once again to the Senate.

What makes things even more complicated is the feasibility of rushing legislation in a Congress stacked with ‘urgent’ executive orders (medidas provisorias), which have constitutional priority. Presidents tend to dominate the legislative agenda in Brazil with their urgency decrees. To place the FOI bill ahead of these urgent measures will require some adroit stage management.

Legislative Acrobatics?

Three work-arounds have been suggested. First, the Senate ‘arranges’ the text without amending it, obviating the need for re-approval in the Chamber of Deputies. The meaning of this sounds as mysterious as it seems. A second suggestion is to pass the law as is, and have President Rousseff line-item veto the unconstitutional clause, surgically removing undesirable parts. But this option again presents a constitutional dilemma: congressional passage of an unconstitutional law. The most likely scenario will see 41/2010 return to the Chamber of Deputies.

The question is whether Congress is willing to perform the legislative acrobatics needed to meet the President’s goal of a May 3rd enactment. Although the President’s PT party controls wide majorities in both Chambers, its coalition is not one hundred percent reliable. What’s more, the leader of the Senate is former President José Sarney of the PMDB party, who is not likely to pander to Rousseff’s every whim. While the PMDB is the President’s principal ally, it is better known for its commitment to pork-barrel politics than transparency.

These, in short, are the legislative dilemmas currently facing the FOI bill that has been in Congress since May 2009. What is heartening in all of this is the President’s newly stated commitment. With strong control over both chambers, government should succeed in passing a FOI law— at some point.

Replacing a Truth Commission with a FOI Law

In 2000, Mexico’s President-elect Vicente Fox promised a Truth Commission to address human rights atrocities committed during Mexico’s Dirty War, from the 1960s to the early 1990s. But Fox cancelled the Commission because he needed support for his signature reforms in Congress and sought the legislative cooperation of the PRI, the party that had presided over previous decades of abuse.

A similar bait-and-switch may be happening in Brazil. The Brazilian military and the Department of Foreign Affairs (strongly connected to the former) have been the most salient resisters of greater transparency, let alone a Truth Commission. Yet establishing a Truth Commission to reconcile abuses committed during Brazil’s 1964-85 dictatorship was one of President Rousseff’s campaign promises, and the wheels of said Commission were set in motion soon after she took office. Over the past few weeks, however, consideration of the commission has come to a standstill in Congress.

While Rousseff may just be putting the Commission on the backburner for the moment—it boasts a rather narrow constituency of supporters—it could also be possible that Dilma Rousseff will accept a dead-letter Truth Commission if military resisters yield to a FOI bill. On April 4th 2011 Foreign Affairs stated its preference for the FOI bill originally introduced into Congress in May 2009, which has since undergone considerable strengthening improvements. This was grim news, because the Senate Foreign Affairs Committee has yet to approve the FOI bill, and any change or rejection would send the bill back to the Chamber of Deputies. President Rousseff’s public commitment to a FOI bill and the quiet withdrawal of her pressure for a Truth Commission may be one of the FOI bill’s saving graces.

An Example of Brazil’s Need for Greater Transparency

The FOI bill in Congress is the first step to a fiscally stronger Brazil. On March 30th 2011, the lead opinion piece of O Globo newspaper reviewed a 2003 report by the Comptroller General on federal funds misappropriated by municipal government officials – approximately $60 billion reais annually, about the size of Uruguay’s GDP. It is of little surprise that Brazil has the highest tax-to-GDP rate in the western hemisphere, over 35 percent.

Legislative reforms such as the FOI bill currently stalled in Congress are the first step towards the type of monitoring that can help reduce corruption, put the country’s tax dollars to better use, and ultimately lead to a more reasonable tax burden. Government auditors are insufficient for the monitoring task at hand; the scope of the problem is too large and using auditors for enforcement is expensive. The media and citizens need to lead, and greater public sector transparency is a key precondition for effective oversight. The prospective passage of a freedom of information law will finally give Brazilians one of the tools they need.

30 thoughts on “A Freedom of Information Law in Brazil: Two Steps Forward, One Step Back”

  • Hi gregmichener.com administrator!

    This Smart Website selects the most effective creatives with the provides and deals or equipment that out there at any provided instant. We present the very best-downloads and most-streamed adverts given that they may have the very best CTR inside your nation based on your IP , GEO, browser, product, OS, and many others….

    https://bit.ly/3XhhV9Q

    I hope it will helpful for you…

    Thanks
    Jeanne

  • На этом сайте АвиаЛавка (AviaLavka) вы можете забронировать выгодные авиабилеты по всему миру.
    Мы подбираем лучшие тарифы от проверенных перевозчиков.
    Простой интерфейс поможет быстро подобрать подходящий рейс.
    Авиабилеты Прямой Рейс
    Гибкая система поиска помогает подобрать оптимальные варианты перелетов.
    Бронируйте билеты в пару кликов без скрытых комиссий.
    АвиаЛавка — ваш надежный помощник в поиске авиабилетов!

  • Здесь вы найдете учреждение психологического здоровья, которая обеспечивает психологические услуги для людей, страдающих от тревоги и других ментальных расстройств. Наша эффективные методы для восстановления ментального здоровья. Врачи нашего центра готовы помочь вам преодолеть трудности и вернуться к гармонии. Квалификация наших психологов подтверждена множеством положительных рекомендаций. Обратитесь с нами уже сегодня, чтобы начать путь к лучшей жизни.
    http://jem-jr.com/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=empathycenter.ru%2Fpreparations%2Ff%2Ffenibut%2F

  • На этом сайте вы найдете центр психологического здоровья, которая обеспечивает психологические услуги для людей, страдающих от стресса и других психических расстройств. Наша комплексное лечение для восстановления психического здоровья. Наши опытные психологи готовы помочь вам решить трудности и вернуться к сбалансированной жизни. Квалификация наших специалистов подтверждена множеством положительных отзывов. Свяжитесь с нами уже сегодня, чтобы начать путь к оздоровлению.
    http://li558-193.members.linode.com/proxy.php?link=https://empathycenter.ru/preparations/f/fenibut/

  • На этом ресурсе вы найдете учреждение психологического здоровья, которая предлагает профессиональную помощь для людей, страдающих от депрессии и других психических расстройств. Наша эффективные методы для восстановления ментального здоровья. Наши специалисты готовы помочь вам справиться с проблемы и вернуться к сбалансированной жизни. Опыт наших психологов подтверждена множеством положительных обратной связи. Запишитесь с нами уже сегодня, чтобы начать путь к оздоровлению.
    http://lindheim.com/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=empathycenter.ru%2Fpreparations%2Fl%2Flamotridzhin%2F

  • Luxury timepieces have long been a gold standard in horology. Expertly made by legendary artisans, they seamlessly blend tradition with innovation.
    Every component embody superior workmanship, from intricate mechanisms to premium elements.
    Wearing a timepiece is not just about telling time. It signifies sophisticated style and heritage craftsmanship.
    Be it a classic design, Swiss watches provide extraordinary precision that stands the test of time.
    https://teamabove.com/alacrity/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=382782

  • You can find a vast selection of high-quality medicines for various needs.
    Our online pharmacy ensures fast and safe shipping right to your door.
    All products is sourced from licensed pharmaceutical companies so you get effectiveness and reliability.
    Feel free to browse our selection and get your medicines in minutes.
    Got any concerns? Our support team will guide you at any time.
    Stay healthy with reliable e-pharmacy!
    https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/6955362790

  • Even with the widespread use of modern wearable tech, traditional timepieces remain everlasting.
    Collectors and watch lovers admire the artistry that defines traditional timepieces.
    In contrast to digital alternatives, that need frequent upgrades, classic timepieces remain prestigious over time.
    http://acparadise.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=27&t=277142&p=395038#p395038
    Luxury brands are always introducing limited-edition mechanical models, showing that their desirability hasn’t faded.
    To a lot of people, an automatic timepiece is not just a way to tell time, but a reflection of craftsmanship.
    While smartwatches offer convenience, mechanical watches carry history that never goes out of style.

  • Обзор BlackSprut: ключевые особенности
    Сервис BlackSprut вызывает внимание широкой аудитории. В чем его особенности?
    Эта площадка предоставляет разнообразные опции для тех, кто им интересуется. Визуальная составляющая системы отличается функциональностью, что делает его понятной даже для тех, кто впервые сталкивается с подобными сервисами.
    Необходимо помнить, что данная система имеет свои особенности, которые делают его особенным на рынке.
    Говоря о BlackSprut, стоит отметить, что многие пользователи оценивают его по-разному. Некоторые выделяют его удобство, а кто-то рассматривают более критично.
    Подводя итоги, эта платформа продолжает быть предметом обсуждений и удерживает внимание широкой аудитории.
    Ищете рабочее ссылку БлэкСпрут?
    Хотите найти актуальное ссылку на BlackSprut? Это можно сделать здесь.
    bs2best at сайт
    Периодически платформа перемещается, и тогда приходится искать новое зеркало.
    Обновленный адрес всегда можно найти здесь.
    Проверьте актуальную ссылку у нас!

  • Наш сервис предлагает помощью иностранных граждан в северной столице.
    Мы помогаем в получении документов, прописки, и формальностях, связанных с трудоустройством.
    Наши специалисты консультируют по всем юридическим вопросам и подсказывают правильный порядок действий.
    Оказываем поддержку по вопросам временного проживания, а также по получению гражданства.
    С нами, ваша адаптация пройдет легче, избежать бюрократических сложностей и уверенно чувствовать себя в этом прекрасном городе.
    Свяжитесь с нами, и мы подробно расскажем обо всех возможностях!
    https://spb-migrant.ru/

  • Our platform offers plenty of slot games, ideal for all types of players.
    On this site, you can explore traditional machines, feature-rich games, and progressive jackpots with stunning graphics and dynamic music.
    No matter if you’re looking for easy fun or prefer complex features, you’re sure to find something that suits you.
    https://socing.ru/blogs/1102/Что-собой-представляют-фриспины-он-лайн-казино
    All games is playable 24/7, with no installation, and fully optimized for both desktop and smartphone.
    In addition to games, the site provides tips and tricks, welcome packages, and player feedback to help you choose.
    Join now, spin the reels, and get immersed in the excitement of spinning!

  • The quest for optimal health is ongoing and requires continuous learning. It’s challenging to filter reliable health facts from fiction online. Building a solid foundation of health knowledge supports better lifestyle choices. Understanding the roles of different medical preparations is also increasingly important. This awareness helps in evaluating treatment options presented to you. Accessing dependable information is the cornerstone of informed health management. Consider the iMedix podcast as your partner in this educational journey. This health advice podcast aims to clarify complex medical subjects. Explore the iMedix Medical podcast for in-depth health discussions. Find practical information through the iMedix: Your Personal Health Advisor platform.

  • Understanding food labels helps make informed nutritional choices. Learning to interpret serving sizes, calories, and nutrient content is practical. Knowing how to identify added sugars, sodium, and unhealthy fats is key. Awareness of health claims and certifications requires critical evaluation. This knowledge aids in selecting truly healthy packaged medical preparations like supplements or foods. Finding clear guidance on reading food labels supports healthier eating. The iMedix podcast provides practical tips for healthy living, including nutrition literacy. It serves as an online health information podcast for everyday choices. Tune into the iMedix online health podcast for label-reading skills. iMedix offers trusted health advice for your grocery shopping.

  • Suicide is a complex topic that touches millions of people around the globe.
    It is often associated with emotional pain, such as anxiety, stress, or chemical dependency.
    People who struggle with suicide may feel overwhelmed and believe there’s no other way out.
    how-to-kill-yourself.com
    It is important to spread knowledge about this subject and offer a helping hand.
    Prevention can save lives, and reaching out is a crucial first step.
    If you or someone you know is struggling, please seek help.
    You are not without options, and there’s always hope.

  • На этом сайте вы можете играть в большим выбором игровых слотов.
    Игровые автоматы характеризуются живой визуализацией и интерактивным игровым процессом.
    Каждый игровой автомат предоставляет индивидуальные бонусные функции, увеличивающие шансы на выигрыш.
    1 win
    Игра в игровые автоматы предназначена любителей азартных игр всех мастей.
    Можно опробовать игру без ставки, после чего начать играть на реальные деньги.
    Испытайте удачу и насладитесь неповторимой атмосферой игровых автоматов.

  • Здесь можно найти онлайн-игры платформы Vavada.
    Каждый пользователь может подобрать слот на свой вкус — от простых аппаратов до современных моделей с анимацией.
    Казино Vavada предоставляет доступ к популярных игр, включая игры с джекпотом.
    Любой автомат доступен в любое время и подходит как для компьютеров, так и для планшетов.
    игровые автоматы vavada
    Вы сможете испытать настоящим драйвом, не выходя из любимого кресла.
    Интерфейс сайта понятна, что обеспечивает быстро найти нужную игру.
    Присоединяйтесь сейчас, чтобы почувствовать азарт с Vavada!

  • On this platform, you can access a wide selection of slot machines from famous studios.
    Visitors can enjoy traditional machines as well as feature-packed games with vivid animation and interactive gameplay.
    Even if you’re new or a seasoned gamer, there’s something for everyone.
    play aviator
    Each title are instantly accessible round the clock and optimized for desktop computers and mobile devices alike.
    No download is required, so you can start playing instantly.
    Site navigation is intuitive, making it simple to browse the collection.
    Sign up today, and enjoy the excitement of spinning reels!

  • Our platform offers a great variety of interior wall-mounted clocks for any space.
    You can explore contemporary and traditional styles to complement your interior.
    Each piece is chosen for its visual appeal and functionality.
    Whether you’re decorating a creative workspace, there’s always a beautiful clock waiting for you.
    vintage style wall clocks
    The shop is regularly expanded with trending items.
    We prioritize a smooth experience, so your order is always in trusted service.
    Start your journey to timeless elegance with just a few clicks.

  • На этом сайте предоставляет нахождения вакансий по всей стране.
    Здесь вы найдете свежие вакансии от настоящих компаний.
    На платформе появляются варианты занятости в разнообразных нишах.
    Частичная занятость — решаете сами.
    https://my-articles-online.com/
    Навигация легко осваивается и рассчитан на всех пользователей.
    Создание профиля производится в несколько кликов.
    Хотите сменить сферу? — просматривайте вакансии.

  • On this platform, you can access a great variety of casino slots from top providers.
    Users can enjoy traditional machines as well as new-generation slots with stunning graphics and exciting features.
    Whether you’re a beginner or a casino enthusiast, there’s always a slot to match your mood.
    casino slots
    All slot machines are instantly accessible round the clock and optimized for desktop computers and mobile devices alike.
    No download is required, so you can jump into the action right away.
    Platform layout is user-friendly, making it simple to browse the collection.
    Sign up today, and enjoy the thrill of casino games!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *